Home
My First Mac



 Help Buying and Getting
 Started with Your New Mac

Snow Leopard Report 3 Weeks In: Meh!

Quick Scan

The good: extra hard drive space, Exchange support.

The bad: older printer and scanner drivers don't work.

The verdict: Meh. Life would be better without it, but not so much that I would reinstall 10.5.

Snow Leopard Report 3 Weeks In: Meh!

Believe it or not, I rarely get Apple products right when they are released. I'm sure most of my friends consider me an Apple fanboy, but I like to think I have a more reasoned approach. But this time, I pre-ordered Snow Leopard from Amazon because it was cheap, and I wanted to see if their slow free shipping would arrive quickly with a pre-order. (It arrived Monday after the launch. Not bad)

I really wanted to like Snow Leopard and find all kinds of little gems. I also wanted it to kick some Windows 7 butt since they will inevitably be compared. So I read up on it in advance and looked forward to exploring what it had to offer. I wanted a little Dazzle. Just $30 worth.

So I installed it on 2 of my 3 Macs the week I got it and have been using it daily ever since. So what has been the result? Meh. And by that, I mean, "what new OS?" It has some advantages and some disadvantages compared to Leopard, but it comes out a wash in my book.

So what didn't I like? Mostly driver issues. I have 2 several thousand dollar (at one time) large format Epson printers that the drivers haven't been updated for. Yes, it's one of those things you can check out in advance and I should have remembered that Epson has ALWAYS sucked at delivering quality Mac drivers for new OS's. But since the problem only comes up every 2 years or so, I tend to forget how much I hate Epson in between releases. (And I do mean hate them. I have a stack of ink cartridges 4 feet high that they won't recycle and there is no after-market for.)

Also, I have a multi function HP printer/scanner that is supposed to work with Snow Leopard but doesn't. It prints, but the scanning software doesn't come up where it supposed to. I may be able to wrangle it into working order somehow, but I just don't have the time for it now.

What's to like in Snow Leopard?
Unfortunately, I can't think of much. I know it's supposed to have a lot of new tech under the hood, but honestly, I can't think of many ways it has improved my Mac experience. There are 2 ways (sort of) that come to mind.

The first is that it takes up less hard drive space. I have one Macbook that is always bumping up against the limit of the internal hard drive. Snow Leopard freed up about 10 GB of space on it, so that's a bonus.

The other major feature is great for some users, just not me. That feature is MS Exchange support. I predict this will be what Snow Leopard is remembered for. Exchange support is the last major barrier preventing Macs from being mainstream business machines. Yes, MS Excel and PowerPoint are not 100% compatible with their Mac versions, but those are smaller issues. Just having Exchange capability in Macs makes them viable to use in a regular business setting. No more having a cheap PC just to run Outlook along side your Mac in the workplace. Yeah!

Too bad it doesn't help me. I'm not on Exchange anymore. But I'm happy for those who need it.

So where do I go from here?  At first I thought about reinstalling Leopard, but fortunately, I have a backup version (that I forgot about) of Leopard on another internal drive. So for now I'm booting into 10.5 when I need the large format printers, which is not too often. Simply, it not so bad that I invest the time to reinstall 10.5 and it's not so good that I invest the time and money to find the work-arounds to make everything run smooth in one OS.

It's just meh.

UPDATE:  See more recent conclusions in the comments.

 
 

This button is an easy way to let readers bookmark articles on Digg, Del.icio.us, Stumbleupon, Google Bookmarks and other services with a single click. You can find out more about Social Bookmarking here.

CLOSE

 
 
 
 
 
 

CLOSE     

 
 







Your Comments:

Apparently Image Capture can make your HP Multi-Function scanner work again. But then the integration with the HP Device manager is gone. It's quite annoying. My HP 7680n allows ethernet connection and a WEB interface that works to scan as well. See if your Epson's are recognized with the Image Capture application


 Avi
 09/24/2009  at  10:20 AM

I had the same issue with my HP. Uninstall the printer then reinstall, works every time.


 Austin
 09/24/2009  at  10:32 AM

I've had worse conversion experiences than yours (both driver-related and my own bull-headedness about making something work my way that bumped into a Leopard permissions bug) — worst experience since my first 64K Mac.

But I'd almost have done it JUST for the nicer Exposé! (Really!) I pull articles thru NetNewsWire then read the couple of dozen Safari articles on the train, and now it's possible to see them laid out so I can pick my next article.

Also, Safari more stable (tho Click2Flash gets credit, too). Finally, it IS a bit snappier and stable when resource-constrained, as this more-than-3-year-old MBP is.


 Walt French
 09/24/2009  at  11:06 AM

You haven't checked out the new Services, where you create your own keystroke-assigned menu actions? They're really cool.


 Anton Barksdale
 09/24/2009  at  04:20 PM

There are printer drivers at epson.com that are described as 10.6.x compatible. I am using them with both my 7880 and my 9600. They work just fine.


 adrianIII
 09/24/2009  at  04:53 PM

It hoses the address book and syncing with mobile.me is all screwed up as well...


 bscenefilms
 09/25/2009  at  11:02 AM

Mail.app works _much_ better with IMAP. I would have paid thirty bucks for that alone. Throw in a few other little nice touches here and there (Stacks, Expose, etc.) and I'm pretty happy with it. No problems here.


 Orc4hire
 09/27/2009  at  06:59 PM

Can't burn DVD's since my upgrade on MacBook internal burner
and on an external LaCie/Pioneer burner.
May have to go back to Leopard.


 Rob Caruso
 09/29/2009  at  05:05 AM

I've had some time to look into the couple issues mentioned above. The scanner issue is resolved by using Image Capture rather than the HP scanning software. Change of workflow, but that;s OK. I wasn't too attached to using the HP app.

The printer driver can be downloaded from Epson and emulated in in Rosetta. The problem is that SL will go look for a driver for you and report back the there aren't any drivers for it. When visiting Epson's 10.6 page, it doesn't list the 4000 as a supported printer, but going back and DLing the 10.5 driver and reinstalling does the trick.

Updated conclusion: Still nothing to love, but I am liking the look of the Dock's pop up menus vs. 10.5's.


 chris Kerins
 10/05/2009  at  02:39 PM

I just upgraded today, and I'm furious that 10.6 (Snow Leopard) does not support Aperture 1.5. I'm not a professional photographer, but I have a ton of photos going back about 10 years, and I bought Aperture a few years ago at the advice of a friend who's a more serious photographer.

After I upgraded to Snow Leopard, I tried to open Aperture, and was told that Aperture 2 is required for compatibility with Snow Leopard. Unfortunately, it's a $99 upgrade, and Aperture 3 is probably due out soon. I'm not about to pay $99 for software that will be obsolete in a month!


 Justin
 12/12/2009  at  10:02 PM

Page 1 of 2 pages  1 2 >

Your response:

Name: Email:

Notify me of follow-up comments

Enter the word you see below:


Remember my personal information

Please keep your comments related to the topic. Personal attacks, offensive language or comments containing advertising will be deleted and you may be banned from MFM.

MFM comments are moderated. It may take a few minutes to a few hours before your comment shows up so we can verify it's not comment spam. Sorry, but we receive spammy comments all day long.

Most Popular Help Topics

Mac Link of the Day

iTunes for Mac: Moving your iTunes Media folder

Learn how to move your iTunes Media folder to a different location on your Mac.

-Apple.com

>> Archive